Following the song, the judges’ critique is unexpectedly harsh. One of the judges expresses significant disappointment, criticizing their choice of song as “a very kind of throwaway song” and pointing out that there are “way better songs” for a swing act to perform . The judge goes on to ask the duo if they were “winding us up the whole time,” suggesting the performance was not taken seriously .
However, the judge gives the duo a crucial second chance, stating, “I’m tempted to hear your second song” . Although the other judges question the decision to allow a second song, they ultimately agree, setting up a high-stakes opportunity for the Soldiers of Swing to prove they are worthy of the BGT stage, with the entire audience eager for their recovery.
For their second chance, the duo launches into a dramatically improved and more appropriate swing song: “Let Me Be a Lady Tonight” . This rendition is significantly stronger, better showcasing their individual vocal talents and demonstrating the potential for their harmonious blend. The judges’ expressions shift from skepticism to genuine appreciation as the performance gains momentum.
Upon finishing the second song, the judging panel is completely won over. Alesha Dixon is the first to apologize, telling the duo, “I just want to say sorry because actually that second song you proved me wrong” . David Walliams adds that their voices work well together, but what truly sells the act is the “friendship and the chemistry” between them, predicting the audience will “really like” them .
Ultimately, the Soldiers of Swing redeem their shaky start with a triumphant finish. The judges praise their likability and charm, and acknowledge that the unpolished, natural chemistry between the two is their greatest asset. They receive a decisive four “Yes” votes from the entire panel, securing their progression in the competition.
You can watch the full audition here:
